Jump to content
johnnyboy

To oil or not to oil....that is the question!

Recommended Posts

Cooking Oil versus PAM type spray

I noticed in the "K11 - Things not to do" thread, a contradiction to my suggestion to using cooking oil.

Oil going rancid concerns me.

I have lots of cast iron cooking pans, and take pride in seasoning them. Part of which means a light coat of cooking oil is re-applied after they're washed (without soap I might add). Then left to sit (ventilated, paper towell folded 4-5 times for thickness is placed between lid and matching pan to allow air circulation) until next time.

May I ask, how does that not go rancid? Or does it, and the heat kills it?

I've been doing this for years, and can honestly say I've never been sick from anything coming off the K.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Part of the issue, Johnnyboydeer, is the breakdown of the oils. They break down in heat, and turn to glop. Different vegetable oils have different temps. That's why some oils are good for deep frying, and others not.

Have you ever felt the sticky on a cookie tray after using PAM on it? Hard to rub that off.

For lubing your cooker, an oil that doesn't turn to glop is best. Vegetable oil can't stand up to the temps that a cooker generates, so the oil doesn't get sticky and freeze your damper or something.

For your cast iron, vegetable oil works fine. If you were to put your frypan in a bonfire, you'd probably burn off all the seasoning. The temps are too high. But part of what is happening under normal circumstances is the oil is making a coating on the iron to protect it. It's no longer slippery grease (or else you could just wipe it off). The oil actually bonds to the metal surface.

Even so, it's recommended that for seasoning you use oils that are high in saturated fats, and therefore less likely to become rancid.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Re: Cooking Oil versus PAM type spray

....I've never been sick from anything coming off the K.
:shock: Even the tile?? :shock::lol:

I couldn't resist. :smt064:smt079

Good one Fetzervalve!!!! I got to hand it to you...

I wrote that not thinking of mental anguish being a sickness.

Adding lost tile to the sick regime, then heck yes, made me sick a lot!!!! Lost my mind many times.... even made me say stuff I didn't need to. :lol:

I'll remember the reminder Fetz; keep your guard up Bud :smt027

:eek:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Part of the issue' date=' Johnnyboydeer.[/quote']

Sannydear, are you putting antlers on me? :lol:

Have you ever felt the sticky on a cookie tray after using PAM on it? Hard to rub that off.

Yes, dear... :wink:

Vegetable oil can't stand up to the temps that a cooker generates' date=' so the oil doesn't get sticky and freeze your damper or something. [/quote']

Understand, but it seems to work much better than the sprays (PAM specifically in my case). I oiled (Olive oil) my top damper threads once, during break-in, and it still spins great like there's oil on it. I haven't looked. Same with the draft door. I also use it to season my grills.

For your cast iron' date=' vegetable oil works fine. If you were to put your frypan in a bonfire, you'd probably burn off all the seasoning. The temps are too high. But part of what is happening under normal circumstances is the oil is making a coating on the iron to protect it. It's no longer slippery grease (or else you could just wipe it off). The oil actually bonds to the metal surface..[/quote']

Do I need to remove my suggestion in the 411 section? I don't want to suggest the idea if it's incorrect? :smt021

Even so' date=' it's recommended that for seasoning you use oils that are high in saturated fats, and therefore less likely to become rancid.[/quote']

What would that type oil be? I know, mineral oil, right? In fact, that's what I use to oil my cutting block. I wouldn't be opposed to putting it on my grill parts.

Would mineral oil work for keeping my cast iron seasoned? I'm not being silly, serious.

Thanks mucho Sanny!!! Appreciate your explaining it. :smt041

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sannydear' date=' are you putting antlers on me? :lol: [/quote']

:reindeer:

Even so' date=' it's recommended that for seasoning you use oils that are high in saturated fats, and therefore less likely to become rancid.[/quote']

What would that type oil be? I know, mineral oil, right? In fact, that's what I use to oil my cutting block. I wouldn't be opposed to putting it on my grill parts.

Would mineral oil work for keeping my cast iron seasoned? I'm not being silly, serious.

Some of the articles I've read suggest lard, hydrogenated cooking oils such as Crisco, and palm or coconut oil. They don't go rancid too easily.

I do confess, I use plain old corn oil or olive oil on my cast iron. Go figger. lol.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some of the articles I've read suggest lard, hydrogenated cooking oils such as Crisco, and palm or coconut oil. They don't go rancid too easily.

I do confess, I use plain old corn oil or olive oil on my cast iron. Go figger. lol.

Yup, Yup, that's me too!

You're the BEST Sanny at finding/using those cool Emoticons!!!!

Who else would have ever thought to look for a "Johnnyboydeer" :reindeer:

No one. See told ya, you're the bomb! :smt073:smt054

Link to comment
Share on other sites

People have used animal fats to season cast iron for as long as they have been around. While it does go rancid if you leave a big globs on the pan, seasoning binds it to the metals and it gets heated when used. For example where not to use it, absolutely don't use vegetable or animal oils on a butchers block, it will turn rancid there for sure.

Just curious, has anyone really needed anything on the KK threads on the damper? After over a year of very heavy use, I have used nothing on my threads. I can still easily spin it closed with a flick of the top. Now there has been times when the top gasket has made the top damper a little harder to open. That was due to over tightening on the warm soft gasket and cold harder gasket didn't want to release (and nothing to do with threads).

I would not recommend putting any kind of oil product on the bottom damper slides. You are just asking for more headache. Oil attracts dirt and ash to the surface which is what is the bottom of the grill is filled with. It would be wiser to thoroughly clean the guide rods and adjust them if necessary. I have never had a need to add any form of lubricants to the grill guides. Only thing in my grill that gets any oiling is the grill grates and that is to aid with cleaning and sticking.

-=Jasen=-

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would not recommend putting any kind of oil product on the bottom damper slides. You are just asking for more headache. Oil attracts dirt and ash to the surface which is what is the bottom of the grill is filled with. It would be wiser to thoroughly clean the guide rods and adjust them if necessary.

I never needed to adjust mine until last weekend when I tightened the small nuts on the back side. Somehow they worked loose and my rods had a bunch of play in them. After tightening, the alignment made them bind up when they were inserted. I cleaned the rods, sprayed them with silicone lubricant spray, wiped them with a paper towel and now all is good as new. Sometimes, you need a little more than cleaning.

BTW, never had to touch the damper top...that thing is still smooth as silk, it almost spins *too* freely, and I use my KK several times a week.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

. I cleaned the rods' date=' sprayed them with silicone lubricant spray, wiped them with a paper towel and now all is good as new. Sometimes, you need a little more than cleaning.[/quote']

While it maybe good as new now, the oil will cause the ash and dirt to stick to the SS over time. So in the long run, it will make matters worse. Maybe you just need more alignment adjustments. As stated, just my recommendation.

-=Jasen=-

Link to comment
Share on other sites

DJ, I think you and FM have hit on something. Not to oil the damper threads.

I like the idea of not oiling at all. However, what we have to remember is KK is not K (some of us come as remnants from the K world, and we appreciate being here).

Meaning KK has stainless threads (if I remember correct) whereas the K has iron threads. Okay, maybe not iron, but steel then, definitely not SS.

I don't remember exactly why I oiled threads the first time; seems to me the they became hard to turn. I thought it was like a creosote that built up, but maybe being combo'd with rust was the real problem. Makes sense you wouldn't have that problem on the KK stainless rod.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I like the idea of not oiling at all. However, what we have to remember is KK is not K (some of us come as remnants from the K world, and we appreciate being here).

Actually JB, my post specifies KK and also this is the KK411 section of the forum. However, if someone asks a specific non KK question, there would be no problem answering it. But in general, this section was created specifically so KK users could ask question about their grill or general KK information given.

Thanks,

-=Jasen=-

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jasen, sorry for including you in my error, by saying we. Wasn't intentional what so ever.

Again, there are times "I" forget the differences (I stand corrected saying "sometimes we forget"), by relating to what I have, and my forgetfullness.

My apology.

Nothing to apologize for.....I simply pointed out facts about this section's and/or my post's intent.

-=Jasen=-

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...