I had been going back and forth over whether to try a leg of lamb for Easter, mainly because based on previous experience, I thought I was looking at having to buy an 8-10 lb. leg of lamb, which would have been way more than the four of us could handle. Luckily, this weekend I found a 3 lb. boneless New Zealand leg of lamb at one of our local stores. Still a lot of meat for a family of four, but much more manageable.
For this cook, I followed a recipe that I found on the Serious Eats website. Here goes.
The rub is a mixture of rosemary, garlic, shallots, red pepper flakes, lemon zest, and anchovies, sautéed in olive oil until the garlic and shallots are tender. After transferring the mixture to a bowl to cool, I added in kosher salt and black pepper, and mixed it up good.
Here’s the leg of lamb, fat side up.
I opened up the leg, and spread about half the rosemary garlic mixture on the inside.
Then I rolled up the leg again, and trussed it up with some butchers twine, because my understanding is that if the leg of lamb opens up when cooking, it’s a big mess.
The remaining rosemary garlic mixture gets rubbed onto the outside. At this point, I could have stuck into the fridge to wait overnight, but I didn’t plan that far ahead.
The leg went into Smaug, who was set up for indirect cooking at 275ºF. I waited until I hit an internal temperature of 130ºF. Here’s what it looked like when it was done.
I took out the heat deflector, fired Smaug up to 500ºF, and direct grilled the outside for about 10 minutes. Here’s the final product.
Sliced open, and served.
It was delicious — super tasty and juicy. The lighting in the sliced open picture makes it look like the outside was cooked much more than it was. In addition, I think lamb holds up better to being cooked to medium than beef does (I like steaks medium rare). Just think of a lamb gyro that’s cooked to well done, and is still juicy and delicious if done right.
Happy Easter!