I also came from a ceramic cooker, a KJ classic, and was trying to decide whether to go with a 23 or 32. I heard the same rationale, and went with the 32 and have not regretted it one bit. If you get the basket splitter, you can adjust the size of the basket for whatever you're cooking, and the multiple cooking grids can create endless setups that will handle most any of your cooking needs. I also second the rotisserie, I have never had better pork loin, leg of lamb, chicken or turkey than what I've produced using the rotisserie. The KJ does still see some action as it's on the deck right outside the kitchen, it's pretty much relegated to hot dogs, brats and fish, the really quick cooks.